Skip to main content
Burger Huyser Attorneys Bedfordview, Johannesburg Family Law Criminal & Commercial Law Litigation Wills & Estates

Article

What a Watching Brief Is

On this page
What is a Watching Brief in South Africa?

By Burger Huyser Attorneys Team
Updated: August 2, 2026

Reading Time: 12 min

A watching brief in South African criminal proceedings is when a legal representative is instructed by a non-party, typically a complainant, state witness, or interested family member, to attend court and observe the matter on that person’s behalf. The mechanism exists because complainants and state witnesses are represented by the State prosecutor under section 20(1) of the National Prosecuting Authority Act 32 of 1998 and have no statutory right to choose their own representative, so the watching brief is the practical way to put independent legal eyes in the courtroom. Per the Mpumalanga High Court’s judgment in Dlamini v S (A24/2023) [2023] ZAMPMBHC 33, watching brief counsel is “exactly what the name says”, counsel briefed to watch the proceedings, and cannot lead evidence, cross-examine witnesses, or address the court on the merits, although section 60(2A) of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977 separately allows the court to take into account the safety views of the person against whom the offence was allegedly committed.

Talk with Burger Huyser Attorneys

A watching brief is a legal representative instructed by a non-party to attend criminal court proceedings on that person’s behalf. The phrase describes exactly what the lawyer does: watches the proceedings and reports back to the client. It is distinct from instructing your own lawyer because complainants and state witnesses are represented by the prosecutor assigned to the court where the matter is scheduled, not by counsel of their choosing. The watching brief therefore fills a procedural gap, it gives the non-party client independent oversight without displacing the prosecutor’s role.

The mechanism is used most often by:

  • Complainants in serious criminal matters who want independent oversight of the case
  • State witnesses who feel exposed or vulnerable and want assurance that the evidence they give is being properly handled
  • Family members of deceased victims, particularly where the family has interests the prosecutor is not advancing
  • Corporate entities with commercial interests in the outcome (for example insurers or employers of the complainant)

The Constitutional and Statutory Backdrop

The watching brief sits at the intersection of two constitutional rights and one statutory framework:

  • Section 35 of the Constitution guarantees the right to legal representation, but only to the accused, not to witnesses or complainants.
  • Section 34 of the Constitution guarantees access to courts, relevant where victims or complainants have separate civil interests in the outcome.
  • Section 20(1) of the National Prosecuting Authority Act 32 of 1998 gives the State prosecutor the title to prosecute and to represent the interests of victims of crime in criminal proceedings.

Because no statute creates a right for a non-party to choose their own representative in a criminal trial, the watching brief is a procedural mechanism developed by the courts rather than a statutory entitlement. Its scope and limits have been set largely by case law, most recently confirmed by the Mpumalanga Division in Dlamini v S in June 2023.

Who Uses a Watching Brief and Why

Across South African criminal courts, from the regional magistrate’s court where most matters begin, through the High Court divisions where serious offences are tried, to the Supreme Court of Appeal and Constitutional Court on further appeal, the watching brief operates the same way because the underlying principle is uniform. The practical reasons clients give for instructing one fall into four categories:

Who Uses a Watching Brief and Why
ReasonWhat it means in practice
Oversight and reassuranceThe client has a legal representative physically present at each appearance who can confirm the matter is being run properly.
Monitoring for undue delaysThe watching brief flags postponements, missing witnesses, and administrative hold-ups so the client can act before a delay becomes entrenched.
Preparing the witnessThe lawyer walks the client through court procedure, etiquette, and how cross-examination actually works before the client testifies.
Flagging procedural irregularitiesAny concerns about how the matter is being handled are recorded and reported back so the client can decide whether to raise them through counsel or the prosecutor.

What a Watching Brief Actually Does in Court

The day-to-day function of a watching brief is narrow but consistent. The lawyer attends each scheduled hearing, sits in the courtroom, follows the evidence and submissions, and reports back to the client after each appearance. The lawyer prepares the client on court procedure and etiquette before testimony, and answers questions about what to expect during cross-examination. Where something unusual happens, a postponement the client wasn’t warned about, a witness who says something inconsistent with a prior statement, a procedural step the client needs to understand, the lawyer flags it.

Critically, the watching brief observes and reports. The lawyer does not lead evidence, does not cross-examine witnesses, and does not address the court on the merits of the case. Those are the actions of a party to the proceedings, and the watching brief represents a non-party.

The Limits: What a Watching Brief Cannot Do

The limits of a watching brief are well settled in South African case law. In Dlamini v S (A24/2023) [2023] ZAMPMBHC 33, handed down on 6 June 2023 by Ratshibvumo J in the Mpumalanga Division of the High Court, the court confirmed that “watching brief counsel is exactly what the name says”, counsel briefed to watch the proceedings only. The judgment cited the Northern Cape decision in Van Heerden & Seuns BK And Others v Senwes Bpk And Others (2005 JDR 0946 (NC)), in which an application by watching brief counsel to take part in trial by questioning witnesses was dismissed, with counsel allowed only to be present and watch.

Three consequences follow from these authorities:

  1. There is no provision in South African law allowing watching brief counsel to actively participate in criminal proceedings as a party.
  2. Where a court permits watching brief counsel to do more than watch, that permission is treated as an irregularity, although per Dlamini v S, the irregularity does not automatically render the bail hearing or trial unfair.
  3. A watching brief cannot substitute for proper representation where the client is the accused; the accused instructs a defence attorney to act as a party.

How a Watching Brief Differs from Instructing Your Own Lawyer

Because the watching brief is sometimes confused with instructing a lawyer to act on your behalf, the practical differences are worth setting out clearly.

How a Watching Brief Differs from Instructing Your Own Lawyer
RoleWho they act forCan address the court on the meritsCan cross-examine witnesses
Watching briefNon-party client (complainant, witness, family)NoNo
Defence attorneyThe accused (a party)YesYes
State prosecutorThe State and the public interest, including victimsYesYes

The watching brief’s value lies precisely in this narrow footprint: the client has informed eyes in the room without confusing the court’s process or stepping on the prosecutor’s role.

The Related Section 60(2A) Mechanism

Section 60(2A) of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977, inserted by the Criminal and Related Matters Amendment Act 12 of 2021, separately requires a court considering bail to take into account the view of the person against whom the offence was allegedly committed regarding their safety. This is the statutory channel by which a complainant’s interest in a bail outcome is brought to the court’s attention, and it is distinct from, and narrower than, a watching brief.

The views under section 60(2A) are typically conveyed through the prosecutor after consultation with the victim, or through evidence from the investigating officer. The provision does not give the complainant or their counsel a right to cross-examine witnesses, and the Dlamini v S court was careful to hold that section 60(2A) does not extend that far either.

In practice, a complainant may instruct a watching brief alongside the section 60(2A) mechanism, the watching brief observes and advises the client privately on how those views are being put, while the statutory channel does the work of formally placing the safety concerns before the court.

When You Might Consider Instructing a Watching Brief

A watching brief is worth considering in any of the following situations:

  • You are a complainant or state witness in a serious criminal matter (such as murder, sexual offences, or assault GBH) and want independent eyes on the proceedings.
  • You are a family member of a deceased victim with a personal interest in the outcome that the prosecutor may not be advancing.
  • You have concerns about procedural irregularities or repeated undue delays in the case.
  • You want your legal team present during testimony to protect your interests or to brief you on what to expect in cross-examination.

The mechanism does not change the outcome of the case. What it provides is informed oversight, someone in the courtroom whose only job is to look after your side of the interests at stake.

How a Watching Brief Is Instructed in Practice

Instructing a watching brief follows a fairly standard sequence:

  1. Approach a law firm with criminal litigation experience that accepts watching-brief instructions.
  2. The firm assesses whether a watching brief is the right mechanism for the situation, or whether the matter should be handled differently, for example through the prosecutor under section 60(2A), or through a separate civil action.
  3. Engagement is typically limited-scope: attend hearings, report back, and flag concerns, not full representation as a party.
  4. Fees are usually charged per appearance or on a monthly retainer basis; the firm should confirm the scope and cost in writing before the first appearance.

Burger Huyser Attorneys’ criminal law practice, led by specialist consultant Clinton Shaw (Criminal Law, with an Assault specialisation) and supported by admitted attorneys including Abrie van der Merwe at the Linden head office, accepts watching-brief instructions alongside its criminal defence and bail-application work. The Linden office (49 First Avenue, Randburg, 2195, 011 888 0246) is the practical intake point for Gauteng-based complainants, state witnesses, and family members who are weighing whether the mechanism suits their matter.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does “watching brief” mean in South African law?

A watching brief is when a legal representative is instructed by a non-party, typically a complainant, state witness, or interested family member, to attend criminal proceedings and observe on the client’s behalf. The lawyer watches the proceedings, prepares the client on court procedure and cross-examination, and reports back, but does not lead evidence, cross-examine witnesses, or address the court on the merits.

Can a watching brief lawyer speak in court?

Under South African case law, most recently confirmed by the Mpumalanga High Court in Dlamini v S (2023), watching brief counsel cannot lead evidence, cross-examine witnesses, or address the court on the merits. Their role is strictly to observe and report back to the client. If a court allows a watching brief to do more than watch, that permission is treated as an irregularity, although it does not automatically render the bail hearing or trial unfair.

Who can instruct a watching brief?

Anyone who is not a party to the criminal proceedings but has a legitimate interest in the outcome, typically complainants, state witnesses, family members of deceased victims, or corporate entities with interests in the trial. The accused cannot instruct a watching brief for themselves; they instruct a defence attorney to act as a party.

How is a watching brief different from a prosecutor?

The State prosecutor is appointed under section 20(1) of the National Prosecuting Authority Act 32 of 1998 and prosecutes the case on behalf of the State, representing the public interest including the interests of victims. A watching brief acts only on the instructions of the client who retained them and has no statutory authority in the proceedings, they observe and report.

When is a watching brief useful?

A watching brief is useful where a complainant or witness wants independent legal oversight, in serious criminal matters (murder, sexual offences, assault GBH), where there are concerns about procedural delays or irregularities, where the witness feels vulnerable, or where the family of a deceased victim wants assurance about how the trial is being run. The mechanism does not change the outcome of the case; it provides the client with informed eyes in the room.

Is there a statutory right to a watching brief?

No. The watching brief is a procedural mechanism developed by the courts, not a right created by statute. Its scope and limits are set by case law (notably Van Heerden & Seuns BK v Senwes Bpk and Dlamini v S). The related statutory channel for bringing a complainant’s interest to the court is section 60(2A) of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977, which requires a court to consider the safety views of the person against whom the offence was allegedly committed.

If you are a complainant, state witness, or family member of a deceased victim and want independent legal eyes on a criminal matter, Burger Huyser Attorneys’ criminal law practice can advise on whether a watching brief is appropriate for your situation and what scope of engagement would suit the case. The practice is led by specialist consultant Clinton Shaw (Criminal Law, Assault specialisation) and supported by admitted attorneys including Abrie van der Merwe at the Linden head office (49 First Avenue, Randburg, 011 888 0246). The firm handles criminal defence, bail applications, and watching-brief instructions through the head office and across its Gauteng branches, and carries a 4.8/5 average across 250+ Google reviews (Trustindex verified “Top Rated Law Firm in South Africa”). Initial consultations are booked through the Linden head office directly.

General Information Disclaimer: This article explains the general legal concept of a watching brief in South African criminal proceedings. It is general information, not legal advice for a specific case. Anyone considering instructing a watching brief, or anyone facing criminal proceedings in any capacity, should consult a qualified attorney with criminal litigation experience about whether the mechanism is appropriate for their situation.

Related Articles:

  • Watching Brief Attorney in South Africa
  • What is a Watching Brief in SA Law?
  • How to Find a Correspondent Attorney in South Africa

CONTACT US

Burger Huyser Attorneys Team

This is a demonstration. The contact form is not connected.

NEED TOP LEGAL SUPPORT IN SOUTH AFRICA? CONTACT OUR LAWYERS TODAY.

Contact our team of experienced law attorneys at Burger Huyser Attorneys to assist you in all matters and procedures.

CONTACT DETAILS

CONTACT US TODAY

  • RANDBURG OFFICE

    011 888 0246 / 061 516 6878

    After Hours Bail Application
    069 522 7696

  • ROODEPOORT OFFICE

    011 668 0030 / 061 516 0091

    After Hours Bail Application
    061 516 0091

  • SANDTON OFFICE

    011 253 3080 / 064 555 3358

    After Hours Bail Application
    064 555 3358

  • PRETORIA OFFICE

    012 471 5700 / 064 548 4838

    After Hours Bail Application
    064 548 4838

  • BEDFORDVIEW OFFICE

    011 201 7190 / 061 536 3223

    After Hours Bail Application
    061 536 3223

  • CENTURION OFFICE

    012 644 4990 / 061 516 7117

    After Hours Bail Application
    069 522 7696

  • ALBERTON OFFICE

    011 439 3990 / 061 515 4699

    After Hours Bail Application
    061 515 4699

  • MIDRAND OFFICE

    010 022 4082 / 064 555 3358

    After Hours Bail Application
    077 274 1932

  • DEBT COLLECTION OFFICE

    011 446 5960 / 079 109 8470

    Monday - Friday; 7:30 AM - 16:30 PM

Speak to Burger Huyser Attorneys

Bedfordview office: 011 201 7190, Monday to Friday, 7:30 AM – 4:30 PM

Request a consultation
Demonstration build by Ozone Development. Not affiliated with or commissioned by this business.