Skip to main content
Burger Huyser Attorneys Bedfordview, Johannesburg Family Law Criminal & Commercial Law Litigation Wills & Estates

Article

What an Antenuptial Contract Is and Why Couples Sign One

On this page

What are the Disadvantages of an Antenuptial Contract?
Burger Huyser Attorneys Team

What are the Disadvantages of an Antenuptial Contract?

By Burger Huyser Attorneys Team
Updated: August 23, 2026

Reading Time: 14 min

An antenuptial contract (ANC) is a notarial contract signed before marriage, executed by an attorney who is a notary public and lodged at the Deeds Office in the area where the parties reside within three months of the marriage, that puts the marriage out of community of property and either retains or excludes the accrual system under the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984. The disadvantages that consistently matter to couples are: the cost (notarial and attorney fees on top of a Deeds Office filing fee), the timing trap (an ANC signed after the wedding is invalid and a late registration requires a High Court condonation application), the loss of automatic growth-sharing between estates when accrual is excluded, the time and expense of calculating an accrual claim at divorce when it is retained, the need for careful separate will and pension planning, and, most consequentially, the Constitutional Court’s 2024 ruling in EB v ER NO and Others, which held that a court may order asset redistribution on divorce even where the parties deliberately contracted out of accrual, eroding much of the contractual certainty an ANC once provided.

Talk with Burger Huyser Attorneys

An ANC is a notarial contract concluded before marriage that sets the matrimonial property regime, out of community of property, with or without the accrual system under the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984. Without an ANC, the default in South Africa is marriage in community of property, in which a single joint estate is created and both spouses hold everything jointly. The ANC is therefore the instrument couples use to opt out of that default and to record in writing how their estates will be treated during the marriage, on divorce, and on death.

Couples typically sign one for creditor protection on one side, to ring-fence pre-marital assets or a family business, to provide for children from a prior relationship, or for estate-planning clarity. None of these motivations insulates a couple from the disadvantages described below; they simply shape which trade-off the couple is willing to accept.

Cost: Notary, Attorney and Deeds Office Fees

The contract must be executed by an attorney who is a notary public, and both parties should ideally obtain independent legal advice before signing, each of these is a separate professional fee. A prescribed fee is also payable to the Deeds Office on registration, on top of the notary’s professional fees for drafting, witnessing and lodgement.

  • DIY online notary services typically advertise an all-inclusive fee in the low-thousands-rand range covering notarial execution and lodgement.
  • Full-attorney drafting with independent legal advice for both parties is materially more expensive, particularly where the fact pattern is unusual (prior marriages, offshore assets, family businesses, anticipated inheritances).
  • Where the contract is signed late or registration is missed, a High Court condonation application adds further attorney-and-correspondent fees on top of the original cost.

Because fees vary with complexity and the level of independent advice each party requires, a notarial quote should be obtained per file rather than relied on as a fixed figure.

Timing: The Pre-Marriage Execution Rule and the Three-Month Registration Window

The ANC must be signed in duplicate by both parties and the notary before the marriage takes place, an ANC signed after the wedding is invalid. The contract must then be lodged at the Deeds Office in the area where the parties reside and registered within three months of the date of the marriage for it to have effect against third parties (such as creditors of either spouse) under section 21(2) of the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984.

Without Deeds Office registration the contract is binding only between the spouses privately and will be ignored by banks, creditors and the High Court. A late registration can be cured by joint application to the High Court under section 88 of the Deeds Registries Act 47 of 1937, with notice to the Registrar of Deeds, but only within a reasonable time after discovery of the non-registration, it is a discretionary, materially more expensive remedy. Couples often underestimate the working time required to draft, execute, lodge and obtain the registration confirmation before the wedding, which is the single most common practical failure point.

Loss of Automatic Growth-Sharing When Accrual Is Excluded

An ANC without accrual means each spouse’s pre-marital assets, assets acquired during the marriage, and income earned during the marriage remain in two completely separate estates. On divorce or death, a non-earning or lower-earning spouse may exit the marriage with only the assets in their own name, regardless of how long the marriage lasted or what indirect contributions (homemaking, child-rearing, career sacrifice) were made.

There is no automatic accrual claim to balance growth between estates before inheritance is applied, so the financially weaker spouse’s only routes to a share of the other estate are a will, a donation, a spouse’s maintenance claim, or a court redistribution order. Distribution on death follows the deceased’s will or intestate succession, there is no accrual claim to top up the survivor’s inheritance before the will is read.

Cost and Complexity of the Accrual Calculation on Divorce (When Accrual Is Retained)

An ANC with accrual preserves separate estates but requires the parties to share the net growth in each estate during the marriage on divorce (or on death), 50/50 by default. The calculation requires:

  1. Opening values (commencement values) for each spouse’s estate at the date of marriage.
  2. Closing values at the date of divorce (or death).
  3. A deduction of any assets expressly excluded from the calculation (inheritances, donations, certain personal damages awards).

The calculation is contentious, frequently requires an actuary or forensic accountant, and is the single most-litigated line item in many ANC divorces. Disputes typically centre on what was in each spouse’s estate at the start of the marriage (and how to prove it years later), how to value illiquid assets (business interests, share portfolios, immovable property), and whether a particular receipt is an excluded inheritance or part of the accruing estate.

The Post-EB v ER Redistribution Risk, The Biggest Change in Modern ANC Practice

The Constitutional Court handed down judgment in EB v ER NO and Others and a Similar Matter 2024 (2) SA 1 (CC), hearing CCT 364/21 and CCT 158/22 jointly. The court read an interim provision into section 7(3) of the Divorce Act 70 of 1979 and held that a court may now order asset redistribution on divorce, on grounds of equity and contribution, even where the parties deliberately contracted out of accrual.

ANCs remain legally valid, but the certainty they once offered, particularly ANCs without accrual, is materially qualified. The General Laws (Family Matters) Amendment Bill was announced by the Minister of Justice as the legislative vehicle to address the gap, but pending enactment, couples relying on the “absolute” protection of an ANC without accrual should plan on the basis that a court may override it.

Estate-Planning Trade-offs: Separate Wills, Pension Treatment and Beneficiary Nominations

An ANC does not replace a will, each spouse still needs a will that disposes of their separate estate, and the surviving spouse’s inheritance comes from the deceased’s will (or intestate succession) rather than from any growth-sharing with the deceased’s estate.

  • Pension interests form part of the relevant spouse’s estate under an ANC and are not automatically shared, but remain subject to the fund’s nomination rules, a spouse’s maintenance claim, and (post-EB v ER) possible court redistribution on divorce.
  • Beneficiary nominations on a life policy or retirement fund can override what the will provides, so an ANC requires a deliberate review of all beneficiary nominations on both sides.
  • Ongoing estate-planning work, joint or separate wills, trust structuring for business or inheritance assets, nomination alignment, is required to maintain the protection the ANC is intended to give. Couples who exclude accrual should expect this work to continue, not stop at execution.

Difficulty of Changing the Regime After Marriage

Changing the matrimonial property regime after marriage requires a High Court application under section 21(1) of the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984, and the parties must have been married for at least two years before the application. The court must be satisfied there are sound reasons for the change and that no third party will be prejudiced, which means creditors, existing beneficiaries and (in some cases) children from prior relationships must be put on notice. The application is a substantive court process, not an administrative amendment, it is materially more expensive than getting the ANC right the first time.

Practical Disadvantages Couples Often Underestimate

Some couples treat the ANC as a purely transactional document and skip independent legal advice for both parties, only to discover at divorce that one party did not in fact understand the consequences of the regime they chose, this can give rise to a challenge to the contract’s validity on the basis of mistake, duress or lack of informed consent. Where one party brings significant pre-marital assets (a family business, an inheritance, a trust interest) and the other does not, the emotionally harder conversations about what each party is bringing into the marriage tend to surface at execution rather than later. An ANC may also be set aside if not properly drafted, witnessed or registered, leaving the couple with the worst of both worlds: they believed they were protected, but the contract is unenforceable against a creditor, the Master, or the divorce court.

Disadvantages by Contract Type, Quick Comparison

Disadvantages by Contract Type, Quick Comparison
DisadvantageANC Without AccrualANC With Accrual
CostNotary + attorney + Deeds Office feeNotary + attorney + Deeds Office fee (often higher, drafting complexity and commencement-value recording)
Timing riskPre-marriage execution; three-month Deeds Office windowPre-marriage execution; three-month Deeds Office window
Loss of automatic growth-sharing on divorceYes, estates stay entirely separatePartial, growth is shared, but pre-marital assets stay with each owner
Divorce complexitySimpler, no accrual claim to argueMore complex, accrual calculation often requires an actuary
Court redistribution powerAvailable under EB v ER (2024)Available under EB v ER (2024)
Estate planningRequires deliberate separate will + beneficiary review for each spouseRequires separate will + beneficiary review + commencement-value record-keeping
Typical best fitCouples wanting full separation; second marriages; creditor-exposed partiesCouples wanting growth-sharing while keeping separate estates

When the Disadvantages Are Worth It (Brief Honest Counterweight)

Despite the trade-offs above, an ANC is often the right choice, full protection from one spouse’s creditors, ring-fenced family-business interests, blended-family planning, and clarity around separate estates are all legitimate reasons to sign one. The point of this article is not to argue against ANCs but to ensure couples considering one understand the full cost, the timing risk, the redistribution overlay, and the downstream estate-planning work the contract entails before they sign.

Antenuptial Contract Disadvantages in South Africa: Why the Regime Is National but the Filing Layer Is Local

The substantive law around the disadvantages of an antenuptial contract, the pre-marriage execution rule, the three-month Deeds Office registration window, the cost of notarial execution and the post-EB v ER redistribution risk, is set out in the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984 and the Deeds Registries Act 47 of 1937 and applies uniformly across South Africa. There is no city-specific rule that changes the answer depending on where a couple lives or plans to marry. What is geographically variable is the registration layer.

The ANC must be lodged at the Deeds Office in the area where the parties reside, and South Africa has multiple Deeds Offices serving different registration districts, couples in the City of Johannesburg, the City of Tshwane (Pretoria), Ekurhuleni, the West Rand and Sedibeng, for example, will lodge at the Deeds Office corresponding to their magisterial district. Where one party lives in one district and the other in another, the practice is to lodge at the Deeds Office where the parties intend to be ordinarily resident after the wedding, and the notary will confirm this at execution. Missed-window condonation applications under section 88 of the Deeds Registries Act run in the High Court division having jurisdiction over the area where the parties reside, which is also a local layer worth confirming before any deadline starts running.

The Legal Practice Council and the relevant Deeds Office remain the authoritative sources for current filing fees and any procedural updates.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the biggest disadvantage of an antenuptial contract?

The single biggest practical disadvantage is the combination of the pre-marriage execution rule and the three-month Deeds Office registration window, if either is missed, the contract is either invalid or unenforceable against third parties without an expensive High Court condonation application. The biggest legal-disadvantage change in recent years is the Constitutional Court’s 2024 ruling in EB v ER NO and Others, which allows a court to redistribute assets on divorce even where the parties contracted out of accrual.

Can an antenuptial contract be signed after marriage?

No. An ANC must be signed before the marriage. An after-the-wedding attempt is invalid. To change the matrimonial property regime after marriage requires a High Court application under section 21(1) of the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984, and the parties must have been married for at least two years.

How much does an antenuptial contract cost in South Africa?

Costs vary with the complexity of the file and the level of independent legal advice each party requires. A DIY online notary service typically advertises an all-inclusive fee in the low-thousands-rand range covering execution and Deeds Office lodgement; full-attorney drafting with independent legal advice for both parties is materially higher, particularly for files involving prior marriages, offshore assets, family businesses or anticipated inheritances. A prescribed fee is payable to the Deeds Office on registration in addition to the professional fees.

What happens if I miss the three-month Deeds Office registration window?

Without Deeds Office registration the ANC is only a private agreement between spouses and will be ignored by banks, creditors and the High Court. Late registration can be cured by joint application to the High Court under section 88 of the Deeds Registries Act 47 of 1937, with notice to the Registrar of Deeds in the area where the parties reside, but the application must be made within a reasonable time after the non-registration is discovered and is a discretionary, materially more expensive remedy than getting it right the first time.

Does an antenuptial contract without accrual protect assets from my spouse’s creditors?

Yes, in the usual case. Insolvency of one spouse does not expose the other’s estate, and assets belonging to the solvent spouse before marriage or received under the ANC are excluded from the insolvent spouse’s estate. The protection is not absolute, creditors with joint debts, maintenance claims, and court-ordered redistribution on divorce can still reach into the protected estate.

Can a court override my antenuptial contract and redistribute assets on divorce?

Yes, following the Constitutional Court’s 2024 judgment in EB v ER NO and Others, a court may order asset redistribution on divorce, on grounds of equity and contribution, even where the parties deliberately contracted out of accrual. ANCs remain legally valid, but the certainty they once offered is qualified. The General Laws (Family Matters) Amendment Bill is the proposed legislative vehicle to address the gap.

Does an antenuptial contract mean I do not need a will?

No, the ANC and the will do different jobs. The ANC sets the matrimonial property regime; the will disposes of each spouse’s separate estate on death. Under an ANC without accrual, the surviving spouse inherits only what the deceased’s will (or intestate succession) provides, so a deliberate will is essential.

Can my antenuptial contract be set aside?

Yes, in limited circumstances. A court can set aside an ANC if it was not properly drafted, witnessed or registered, if one party did not give informed consent, or if there was fraud, duress or mistake. Couples who skip independent legal advice for both parties are more exposed to a validity challenge later.

If you are weighing the disadvantages of an antenuptial contract and want a clear-eyed view of whether the regime still suits your circumstances, particularly in light of the EB v ER redistribution ruling, Burger Huyser Attorneys’ Family Law team can take you through the trade-offs, draft the contract, attend to independent legal advice for both parties, and execute and lodge it through an admitted notary. The firm has notaries on staff (Natasha van Deventer and Amanda le Roux, both based at the Bedfordview branch) and branches across Gauteng, call the Randburg head office on 011 888 0246 or your nearest branch to book a first consultation, and bring your ID documents, prior marriage details (if applicable) and a list of pre-marital assets either party wants expressly addressed in the contract.

General Information Disclaimer: This article describes the general legal framework around the disadvantages of an antenuptial contract in South Africa under the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984, the Deeds Registries Act 47 of 1937, the Divorce Act 70 of 1979 and the post-EB v ER (2024) redistribution landscape. It is general information, not legal advice for a specific marriage, divorce or estate plan. Couples considering an ANC should consult a qualified attorney admitted as a notary public to confirm current requirements, fees, the post-EB v ER redistribution overlay, and any updates to the General Laws (Family Matters) Amendment Bill before signing.

CONTACT US

 

This is a demonstration. The contact form is not connected.

NEED TOP LEGAL SUPPORT IN SOUTH AFRICA? CONTACT OUR LAWYERS TODAY.

Contact our team of experienced law attorneys at Burger Huyser Attorneys to assist you in all matters and procedures.

CONTACT DETAILS

CONTACT US TODAY

  • RANDBURG OFFICE

    011 888 0246 / 061 516 6878

    After Hours Bail Application
    069 522 7696

  • ROODEPOORT OFFICE

    011 668 0030 / 061 516 0091

    After Hours Bail Application
    061 516 0091

  • SANDTON OFFICE

    011 253 3080 / 064 555 3358

    After Hours Bail Application
    064 555 3358

  • PRETORIA OFFICE

    012 471 5700 / 064 548 4838

    After Hours Bail Application
    064 548 4838

  • BEDFORDVIEW OFFICE

    011 201 7190 / 061 536 3223

    After Hours Bail Application
    061 536 3223

  • CENTURION OFFICE

    012 644 4990 / 061 516 7117

    After Hours Bail Application
    069 522 7696

  • ALBERTON OFFICE

    011 439 3990 / 061 515 4699

    After Hours Bail Application
    061 515 4699

  • MIDRAND OFFICE

    010 022 4082 / 064 555 3358

    After Hours Bail Application
    077 274 1932

  • DEBT COLLECTION OFFICE

    011 446 5960 / 079 109 8470

    Monday - Friday; 7:30 AM - 16:30 PM

Speak to Burger Huyser Attorneys

Bedfordview office: 011 201 7190, Monday to Friday, 7:30 AM – 4:30 PM

Request a consultation
Demonstration build by Ozone Development. Not affiliated with or commissioned by this business.